Impostor Syndrome

Also known as: Impostor phenomenon, Fraud syndrome

Impostor syndrome (also known as impostor phenomenon) is a psychological occurrence in which an individual doubts their skills, talents, or accomplishments and has a persistent internalized fear of being exposed as a 'fraud'. Despite external evidence of their competence, those experiencing this phenomenon remain convinced that they are frauds and do not deserve all they have achieved.

Social Biases

2 min read

observational Evidence


Impostor Syndrome

The Psychology Behind It

Impostor Syndrome is not a formal psychiatric disorder, but rather a psychological pattern where individuals doubt their accomplishments and have a persistent, often internalized fear of being exposed as a "fraud." Despite external evidence of their competence, those experiencing this phenomenon remain convinced that they are frauds and do not deserve all they have achieved. They often attribute their success to luck, timing, or deceiving others into thinking they are more intelligent or competent than they believe themselves to be.

First described by psychologists Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes in 1978, it was originally thought to apply mostly to high-achieving women. However, subsequent research has shown that it affects both men and women across various demographics. It is often driven by perfectionism, a fear of failure, and a tendency to discount positive feedback while magnifying negative feedback.

Real-World Examples

High-Achieving Professionals

Many successful CEOs, doctors, and academics report feeling like they are just "winging it" and that any day now, someone will walk into their office and tell them they don't belong there. Even after winning prestigious awards, they may feel the award was a mistake or that the competition was weak.

Students in Higher Education

Graduate students often feel that the admissions committee made a mistake in accepting them. They may look at their peers and think everyone else is brilliant and belongs there, while they are struggling to keep up, unaware that many of their peers feel exactly the same way.

Creative Arts

Artists, writers, and musicians often feel that their work is not "real" art or that their success is due to a fluke. A writer might publish a bestseller and worry that they will never be able to write another good book, attributing the first one to luck rather than skill.

Consequences

Impostor Syndrome can lead to:

  • Burnout: Individuals may overwork themselves to prove they are not frauds, leading to exhaustion and stress.
  • Missed Opportunities: Fear of being exposed may prevent people from applying for promotions, speaking up in meetings, or taking on challenging projects.
  • Anxiety and Depression: The constant fear of exposure and self-doubt can take a significant toll on mental health.
  • Reduced Innovation: People may stick to safe, conventional methods rather than taking risks, for fear of failure exposing their perceived incompetence.

How to Mitigate It

Overcoming Impostor Syndrome involves reframing how you view your own competence and success.

  1. Acknowledge the Feelings: Recognize when you are having impostor thoughts. Label them: "This is impostor syndrome, not reality."
  2. Talk About It: Share your feelings with trusted mentors or peers. You will often find that many of them feel the same way, which helps normalize the experience.
  3. Document Your Success: Keep a "brag file" or a record of your achievements, positive feedback, and successful projects. Review it when you are feeling doubtful.
  4. Reframe Failure: View failure as a learning opportunity rather than proof of your incompetence. Even experts make mistakes.

Conclusion

Impostor Syndrome is a common experience that affects many high achievers. It is a distortion of reality where self-perception lags behind actual performance. By recognizing these thought patterns and actively challenging them, individuals can learn to internalize their success and recognize their own worth.

Mitigation Strategies

Fact-Checking Feelings: When you feel like a fraud, list three pieces of objective evidence that prove you are qualified (e.g., degrees, past successful projects).

Effectiveness: high

Difficulty: moderate

Mentorship: Find a mentor who can provide objective feedback on your performance and help you calibrate your self-assessment.

Effectiveness: high

Difficulty: moderate

Good Enough: Practice accepting 'good enough' work instead of striving for perfection on every task. This reduces the pressure that fuels impostor feelings.

Effectiveness: medium

Difficulty: moderate

Potential Decision Harms

Talented individuals may turn down promotions or leave high-potential career paths because they believe they are not qualified.

major Severity

Employees may withhold innovative ideas in meetings for fear of being judged, stifling organizational growth.

moderate Severity

Chronic stress from maintaining the 'mask' of competence can lead to severe anxiety and burnout.

major Severity

Key Research Studies

The Impostor Phenomenon in High Achieving Women: Dynamics and Therapeutic Intervention

Clance, P. R., & Imes, S. A. (1978) Psychotherapy: Theory, Research & Practice

Identified the impostor phenomenon in high-achieving women who persisted in believing they were not bright and had fooled anyone who thought otherwise.

Read Study →


Related Biases

Explore these related cognitive biases to deepen your understanding

Risky Shift

9 min read

Risky shift is the tendency for groups to make riskier decisions than individuals would make alone, especially when responsibility is diffused across members.

Social Biases / Group decision-making

/ Group Risk-Taking

Abilene Paradox

9 min read

The Abilene paradox is a group decision-making failure where people agree to a course of action that almost no one individually wants, because each assumes others are in favor.

Social Biases / Group decision-making

/ False consensus decision

Zero-Sum Bias

2 min read

Zero-sum bias is a cognitive bias towards thinking that a situation is a zero-sum game, where one person's gain would be another's loss.

Social Biases

/ Fixed pie bias

Correspondence Bias

9 min read

Correspondence bias is the tendency to infer stable personality traits from others' behavior while underestimating situational influences.

Social Biases / Attribution and impression formation

/ Fundamental Attribution Error

Trait Ascription Bias

8 min read

Trait ascription bias is the tendency to see others' behavior as reflecting fixed traits, while viewing our own behavior as more flexible and influenced by circumstances.

Social Biases / Self–other perception

/ Self–Other Asymmetry

Hostile Attribution Bias

9 min read

Hostile attribution bias is the tendency to interpret ambiguous actions of others as intentionally hostile or threatening.

Social Biases / Attribution and aggression

/ Hostile Attribution of Intent